Joined: 04 Mar 2008
Location: Williamsburg, VA
This article in Sporting Classics Daily questioning whether hunting is a sport is definitely thought provoking. Although written in the context of big game hunting, I think it would also apply to upland hunting.
When folks ask me what I do for fun, I mention that I enjoy shooting "sports" like skeet, sporting clays, wobble trap, etc., and target shooting. I generally add that I also enjoy fishing and upland bird and water fowl hunting, that might imply that I think hunting is also sport. Although I have never thought about it until now, I agree with the author that hunting should not be considered "sport."
Joined: 27 Dec 2005
Location: Great Lakes
First thought is "sport" implies some sort of person vs person or team v team competition. Then there are things like mountain climbing, jogging, etc. Still, hunting & fishing don't strike me as being "sports".
_________________ A Springer Spaniel, a 6# double and a fair day to hunt.
Joined: 09 Dec 2009
Location: Cheyenne, Wy
Well, that is a good question. I believe shooting clays in any form to be a "sport".
Hunting to me though, is a way of life, as there is no real way to analyze how well you did.
The outcome of hunting is not determined by anyone other than the person doing the hunting. It is something you want to do, whether you do it better than anyone else doesn't make a difference, just the feeling you get at the end of the day.
I may not have expressed this very well, but hunting is way more than a "sport".
_________________ One man with courage makes a majority.
Is upland hunting a sport?....sure, when compared to subsistence hunting.
Most are not hunting upland game to live.
Is upland hunting a sport re a competition aspect?....sure, it can be.
There are aspects of competition, informal competition, when hunting upland species such as dove and, sadly, with the ruffed grouse in a RGS event....supposed good intentions notwithstanding.
Is upland hunting an activity requiring a measure of athletic prowess and developed skill with tools?....sure X3, to the degree necessary to be both successful and ethical in the process.
Not sure why the term "sport" re upland hunting is ever considered a negative.
The positives surrounding it, such as support for diverse Habitat/timber age classes and for many species, upland game and not, has long been clear.
Granted, upland hunting can be misunderstood by that percentage of the Public never exposed to it or to the above positives but that applies to folks not understanding or appreciating many things which they were never exposed to in other than a negative light or a cursory fashion.
It is particularly odd to me to hear a deer hunter, for example, speak of great moral values when, today, they have been the sport which has been particularly selfish in the negatives they occasion by their own passion.....from increased nest predators, baiting on a time clock 365/7 and the mantra of Locate, Lease & Lock Up to name just a few and then on to the reality of sucking away attention, will and dollars from many DNRs, if a critter does not grow antlers or gobble.
Spare me the big game deer hunter chatter re respected quarry and spiritual partnership(good grief) when the evidence at present over my area of the country indicates just the opposite if apart from their own preference.
I wonder what Aldo would think of deer hunting today.
I reckon not much as Mr. Leopold saw when he looked.
Sportsmen-Conservationist is a moniker applied far too widely and inaccurately these days, to me.
Be nice to read more articles that honestly note and address when "sport" hunting passion gigs other critters, again game and not, along with habitat right smack in the short ribs.
'Course, that will not happen as so many believe that any actions afield when ranked as Legal are all that matter, one should never speak ill of a fellow hunter and we must all stand together.
Too sad, all of those.
IF, more matters than the individual.
We do need another Aldo Leopold....I wonder tho if many would agree with a man who honestly saw and who noted missteps or, especially,...... noted that "fierce, green fire."
Last edited by tramroad28 on Tue Feb 14, 2017 9:40 am; edited 2 times in total
There is competition in Live Bird Shooting, Big Game Fishing etc. So I guess some parts of hunting may be considered a "Sport" Sure that the "Game" we hunt, do not see it all that "Sporting" unless we give them the chance to hunt back!
_________________ Robert Kittine
Sag Harbor and Manhattan, New York
16 Gauge O/U Browning 525 Sporting
16 Gauge SxS Dickinson Estate (Soon I Hope)
16 Gauge Pump Browning BPS Upland
16 Gauge Semi-AutoRemington 1100 Sporting
Single Shot ???
Joined: 02 Dec 2005
Location: Plains, MT.
I like fn16ga and his outlook. The only thing I can add is being older and living a pretty simple retirement I find great pleasure in not having to explain my life style choices to anyone and at the same time I don't feel the need to seek justification or even an explanation from my fellow hunters. Call hunting what one may, it is fun and rewarding to me. The meals provided are pretty good also. I also don't consider Curling a sport, but that is a discussion for another time.
Joined: 05 Nov 2005
Location: Sussex Wisconsin
I don't care what you call it....but I don't like the have to limit out attitude of some...I enjoy being outside, enjoy the birds, and if I am in the mood for a wild game meal I might pull the trigger.....otherwise I feel just as fulfilled coming home with my game vest empty.........
I also don't consider Curling a sport, but that is a discussion for another time.
Hey now no need to get personal, Wi. takes Curling very seriously and the Centerville Curling Club is pretty close to Dave Erickson's place Just saying....
Couple of years ago developed degenerative arthritis in my left ankle which is now spreading to other parts of my body. Kind of hard to bird hunt when you can hardly walk. Mayo Clinic told me there is really not much they can do for it except for a brace which did nothing. So had my primary care physician refer me to Mayo Clinic Sports Medicine on a long shot.
Took me 3 phone calls to get in. The admin assistant wanted to know what sports I played. I said hunting with the dog and she seemed confused and said that didn't qualify. EXOS and Mayo Sports Med is one of the top places in the world and works with pro athletes, special forces, etc. And I work at Mayo LOL but they wouldn't see me because I didn't currently play a "sport". Third time was a charm and I got smarter finally. Told them I couldn't play golf anymore and got in. Only golf I have played in last 20 years is to roll old golf balls down the rib of my barrels flip them in the air and shoot them. And slice them with bird shot as well as I do with a driver. But apparently it is a sport.
They have helped a lot with custom orthotics to prevent bone on bone grinding in the ankle. And guided cortisone shots. But guess according to the world at large hunting is not a sport.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum